| Description | Card Number | PR 1 | Good 2 | VG 3 | VG-EX 4 | EX 5 | EX-MT 6 | NM 7 | NM-MT 8 | MT 9 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commons | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | ||
| Charlie Grimm | 1 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 40 | 115 | ||
| John Antonelli | 2 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 40+ | 150 | ||
| Vern Bickford | 3 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 40+ | 115 | ||
| Bob Buhl | 4 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | |
| Lew Burdette | 5 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 90 | ||
| Dave Cole | 6 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | |
| Ernie Johnson | 7 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | |
| Dave Jolly | 8 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | |
| Don Liddle | 9 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | |
| Warren Spahn (HOF) | 10 | 5 | 10 | 15 | 25 | 50 | 75 | 135 | 265 | 750 | |
| Max Surkont | 11 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | |
| Jim Wilson | 12 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 95 | ||
| Sibby Sisti | 13 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | |
| Walker Cooper | 14 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | |
| Del Crandall | 15 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 40+ | 50+ | 110 | ||
| Ebba St. Claire | 16 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | |
| Joe Adcock | 17 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50+ | |||
| George Crowe | 18 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | |
| Jack Dittmer | 19 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | |
| Johnny Logan | 20 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | |
| Ed Mathews (HOF) | 21 | 10 | 15 | 25 | 35 | 70 | 100 | 150 | 300 | ||
| Bill Bruton | 22 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | |
| Sid Gordon | 23 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 | |
| Andy Pafko | 24 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 45+ | 75 | ||
| Jim Pendleton | 25 | 5+ | 10+ | 15+ | 20+ | 25+ | 30+ | 35+ | 50- | 125 |